|
That
big monstrous pool in many multi-purpose health clubs that gobbles up cash
during the heating season, may serve a useful function for the aging
population. Osteoarthritis (OA) is a degenerative form of
arthritis affecting many older adults over the
age of 50. It is the most common type of arthritis and its prevalence
continues to increase along with an aging worldwide population. Commonly
affecting the spine, hands, hips and knees, OA can result in significant
pain and disability.
Various forms of exercise have been shown to improve OA symptoms and
even delay the progression of the disease, especially muscle strengthening
programs. However, until a recent study the benefits of water-based
exercise was not known.
Functional Gains With
Hydrotherapy
Hydrotherapy, or water exercise in a
heated pool, was found in a recent study
to improve strength and mobility in elderly patients with arthritis of the
hip and knee. This is according to a study in the December issue of the
Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases.
"The surprise in this study was that
there was any functional gain in the hydro group," says lead author Maria
Crotty, head of the Flinders University department of rehabilitation and
aged care in Adelaide, Australia.
"We expected the patients would like
hydro, but actually the gym group would get the gains. In fact, both
exercise groups did pretty well, so it provides some support for hydro,"
she adds.
In a randomized controlled trial
involving 105 participants, hydrotherapy (water-based resistance exercise)
was directly compared to gym-based exercise (land-based resistance
exercise) during 2001-2002.
The study has shown that both forms
of exercise produce positive but different benefits, as the hydrotherapy
group showed greatest improvement in walking distance and the gym group
demonstrated greatest improvement in quadriceps strength.
Gym-Based Resistance Exercise Is Also Useful for Osteoarthritis
It
can be concluded from these results that hydrotherapy programs are
effective in improving physical function and possibly cardio-vascular
fitness, especially when pain or disability prevent extended periods of
weight bearing exercise (e.g. walking). However, for increasing strength
around affected joints in order to improve joint stability and improve
shock-absorbing capacity, gym-based resistance exercise is significantly
more effective in achieving this.
Exercise often is recommended for
people suffering from osteoarthritis, the most common form of arthritis
and one in which the risk increases with increasing age and weight. While
water exercise is extremely popular (and expensive), to date there has
been little evidence in support of pool therapy, say the study authors.
"Hydrotherapy is very useful with
overweight patients who find aerobic exercise difficult (often they have
painful knees and/or hips)," Crotty writes. "Osteoarthritis is a growing
problem in overweight populations, and the common advice is [to] walk, but
many of this patient group are reluctant or unable to walk."
If you want to focus on
strengthening muscles, however, it's probably more efficient to use the
gym, she adds. |